America forgot how to disagree, but the Shabbat table remembers

In my new book, Free Expression Under Fire, I make an argument I’ve spent years defending: that free expression doesn’t just live in the courtroom or the ivory towers where I trained. My case is that the First Amendment’s 45 words have durable meaning when ordinary people take them out of litigation briefs and law reviews and into “kitchen table conversations, coffee shop debates and civic discussions that shape our communities.”I stand by that. But I left something out. This month, as Carnegie Mellon University investigated eight students over hateful messages painted on a campus wall and a university chancellor accused his peers of “hiding behind freedom of speech” to avoid confronting antisemitism, I kept thinking that our institutions of higher education have made a genuinely hard question look impossible.Where does free expression end and real harm begin? The deans convene task forces. The lawyers draft speech codes. Yet every…
The author argues that while American institutions struggle with free expression, the Shabbat dinner table serves as a unique and effective forum for civil discourse. Unlike online platforms built for exit, Shabbat is "built for return," fostering continued engagement despite disagreements. The article highlights that the embodied nature of the Shabbat table, where participants are family, prevents the dehumanization often seen in online interactions. Drawing parallels between the First Amendment and Talmudic tradition, which preserves minority opinions, the author suggests both share a belief that "truth is better served by keeping the argument open than by shutting it down." The piece encourages patience and the discipline of staying at the table, emphasizing that the relationship should outweigh disagreements, offering a vital lesson for a fractured society.
© All rights to the original article belong to the source. Din Online shows a headline, an excerpt and a link only. The objectivity rating is computed automatically and is an estimate only.
Discussion
No comments yet — be the first to comment.