Over Jewish concerns, Bay Area district votes 5-0 to use ethnic studies textbook

Trustees of the Campbell Union High School District, which operates six high schools with 8,600 students in the San Jose, Calif., area, voted 5-0 to adopt the textbook “Voices: An Ethnic Studies Survey” for six years for its ethnic studies courses.The book “mentions Jews but lacks a meaningful discussion of what antisemitism is, how it works and why it has risen dramatically since the Hamas massacre on Oct. 7, 2023,” according to Oleg Ivanov, executive director of the northern California region for StandWithUs.“It distorts Jewish identity and experiences by ignoring Jews, who are not ‘white’ in any sense of the term, as well as antisemitic threats from white supremacists and other hate groups,” he told JNS. “It teaches about ‘diaspora’ communities but never mentions how that word is rooted in Jewish history.”The textbook, which the district board adopted at a meeting on Thursday night, is to be part of a…
The Campbell Union High School District in San Jose, California, voted 5-0 to adopt the textbook “Voices: An Ethnic Studies Survey” for its ethnic studies courses, despite significant concerns raised by Jewish community organizations and parents. Critics, including StandWithUs and the Bay Area Jewish Coalition, argue that the textbook distorts Jewish identity and experiences, lacks a meaningful discussion of antisemitism, and uses terms like “resistance” without clear definitions. Oleg Ivanov of StandWithUs stated, “It distorts Jewish identity and experiences by ignoring Jews, who are not ‘white’ in any sense of the term.”
Parents and students repeatedly warned that the concern was never the textbook. It was the unchecked supplemental materials.
The decision follows a California Department of Education finding in April 2025 that the district’s ethnic studies materials and instruction discriminated against Jewish students. Concerns were also raised about unvetted supplementary materials and a teacher's assignment asking if Hamas members are terrorists or freedom fighters. District officials, however, maintained that the vote was specifically on the textbook, not the broader curriculum or graduation requirement, with Superintendent Robert Bravo noting a lack of specific objections to the book's factual accuracy.
© All rights to the original article belong to the source. Din Online shows a headline, an excerpt and a link only. The objectivity rating is computed automatically and is an estimate only.
Discussion
No comments yet — be the first to comment.