שבת, נובמבר 21, 2026 עברית|English Log in Free sign-up
World

Public universities decide what and how to teach, not professors, federal court rules

אוג 17, 2026 ·  Source: JNS 86Objectivity score86/100

Public universities decide what and how to teach, not professors, federal court rules

A group of Indiana professors can’t challenge the state’s intellectual diversity law, which requires them to teach a range of political and ideological views to be considered for tenure and promotion, a federal appeals court ruled last week, affirming a lower court’s decision.One of the professors who sued said that he feared that he would be required to teach pro-Israel views.Joshua Kolar, a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, wrote in the ruling that many students want to get an education in which professors don’t stray from their areas of expertise and assigned courses.“If plaintiffs are right, colleges that make such promises to students—and their paying parents—are powerless to deliver on them,” the judge ruled. “Faculty may choose to provide tendentious screeds instead, denying their institutions the ability to provide students with a particular kind of educational experience.”The Seventh Circuit case of McDonald v. Trustees…

💬 רוצים להגיב ולהצטרף לדיון? הצטרפו — חינם, ומקבלים גם את הדיג׳סט השבועי.
🗞️ In-depth summary

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit recently affirmed a lower court's decision, ruling against a group of Indiana professors who challenged the state's intellectual diversity law. This law mandates that professors teach a range of political and ideological views to be eligible for tenure and promotion. One professor expressed concern about potentially being required to teach pro-Israel views. The court determined that public universities, not individual professors, hold the authority to decide curriculum content and teaching methods. Judge Joshua Kolar stated, "If plaintiffs are right, colleges that make such promises to students—and their paying parents—are powerless to deliver on them." The court concluded that the professors lacked standing for their First Amendment claims, as the policy grants universities the power to set educational guidelines.

Automatically generated summary based on the original article; quotes are from the source.
This story is based on reporting by JNS.
Read the full article at the source →
🏷

© All rights to the original article belong to the source. Din Online shows a headline, an excerpt and a link only. The objectivity rating is computed automatically and is an estimate only.

Related

Discussion

No comments yet — be the first to comment.

Add a comment