The Haredi draft: How a limited deferment turned into a national dispute
Few disputes have proved as durable—or as politically disruptive—in Israel as the deferment of military service for Haredi yeshivah students. The issue has repeatedly reached the Supreme Court, destabilized governing coalitions and become one of the country’s defining debates over equality and burden-sharing.Yet the arrangement did not begin as a broad exemption for Haredi men. It began as a limited administrative accommodation, introduced under the exceptional conditions of Israel’s founding and intended to protect a small number of full-time Torah scholars. Over the following decades, however, demographic growth, political bargaining and the incentives created by the deferment system transformed that narrow measure into an institution around which Haredi society increasingly organized itself.The central question is how that transformation occurred: how a bounded concession became the basis of a broad social system, and why reversing it eventually became far more difficult than creating it had been.In 1948, as the new state…
The exemption of ultra-Orthodox yeshivah students from IDF service, a contentious issue in Israel, began in 1948 as a limited administrative accommodation for a few hundred Torah scholars. This initial arrangement, accepted by Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion, aimed to protect the remnants of Europe's yeshivah world after the Holocaust, allowing the defense minister to defer service for a small, specified number of students. Dr. Gilad Malach of the Israel Democracy Institute noted, "The deal was support for the state and recruitment into the army, while allowing those studying Torah to build a rabbinical elite."
- Over decades, demographic growth and political bargaining transformed this narrow measure into a broad system.
- In 1977, under Menachem Begin's government, the numerical quota on yeshivah deferments was removed, shifting eligibility to depend on enrollment and full-time study.
- This change, combined with incentives to remain in yeshivah to avoid conscription, led to the deferment system shaping Haredi society's educational and employment decisions.
© All rights to the original article belong to the source. Din Online shows a headline, an excerpt and a link only. The objectivity rating is computed automatically and is an estimate only.
Discussion
No comments yet — be the first to comment.