שבת, נובמבר 21, 2026 עברית|English Log in Free sign-up
World

The son who never was … until he was

אוג 17, 2026 ·  Source: JNS 81Objectivity score81/100

The son who never was … until he was

Sadly, some people still believe that the Torah is ancient and obsolete. In my congregation, whenever I give a sermon that touches on the weekly portion and contemporary events, the audience no longer marvels at how relevant the Torah is in our generation. It is a regular occurrence and now presumed by my listeners to be so.Clearly, the Torah is anything but obsolete. It talks to us in the uncanniest ways.This week’s Torah reading contains a passage that bothered me for many years. It hasn’t in recent times, though that’s not necessarily good news.In Parshat Ki Teitzei, we read about a boy who is stubborn, rebellious, a glutton, a drunkard. He is completely deaf to the appeals and pleas of his father and mother. Eventually, his parents haul him before the elders of the city. If the court finds against him, that’s it—the death penalty. Not for stealing a car…

💬 Want to join the discussion and comment? Sign up — free, and get the weekly digest too.
🗞️ In-depth summary

The article discusses the Torah's law of the "stubborn and rebellious son" (ben sorer u'moreh) from Parshat Ki Teitzei, a passage that prescribes the death penalty for a gluttonous, drunken, and disobedient teenager. The author notes that the Talmudic rabbis, particularly Rabbi Yehuda, interpreted this law with such stringent conditions—requiring specific ages, theft from parents for particular items, and parents who look and sound alike—that they concluded, "This never happened, and it never will." They viewed it as a theoretical case for study or a deterrent.

“I saw one. And I sat by his grave!”

However, the author, initially agreeing with Rabbi Yehuda, now believes that Rabbi Jonathan's dissenting view—"I saw one. And I sat by his grave!"—is tragically relevant today. The author argues that the modern equivalent of the ben sorer u'moreh is a teenager who develops an expensive drug habit, leading them to steal from their parents. This phenomenon, once considered impossible in "good homes," is now prevalent, necessitating rehab centers and rabbinic intervention. The article concludes with a plea for parents to be vigilant, trust their children but not blindly, and seek professional help immediately if something seems amiss, emphasizing the need to fill any void left by addiction with positive, spiritual meaning.

Automatically generated summary based on the original article; quotes are from the source.
This story is based on reporting by JNS.
Read the full article at the source →
🏷

© All rights to the original article belong to the source. Din Online shows a headline, an excerpt and a link only. The objectivity rating is computed automatically and is an estimate only.

Related

Discussion

No comments yet — be the first to comment.

Add a comment