America, beware: The battle over Israel’s identity could be coming for the US – opinion

The article argues that the United States should observe the ongoing battle over Israel's identity, as similar challenges could soon face America. The author, a fourth-generation American and first-generation Israeli, contends that both nations, despite their differences, share commonalities as young, modern states with ancient inheritances, having fought for independence and become melting pots. The piece highlights a propaganda campaign against Israel that employs "role reversal," recasting Israel as Goliath and the Palestinians as David, thereby questioning Israel's legitimacy rather than just its actions. This framework, which moves from "did wrong" to "is wrong," could similarly be applied to America, challenging its historical figures and national identity. The author emphasizes that both democracies are approaching consequential elections amidst profound arguments over national identity, and warns that external manipulation can lead citizens to lose confidence in their society's foundational narrative. The article concludes by urging Americans to critically examine their changing attitudes toward Israel, recognizing that "America's imperfections do not erase America. Israel's imperfections do not erase Israel."